by Carlus Gupton
Many church leaders today feel exhausted.
The emotional temperature of public life seems to rise every year. Social media amplifies outrage. News cycles accelerate conflict. Cultural debates once confined to politics now spill directly into congregational life. Elders and ministers who entered ministry to shepherd people toward Christ increasingly find themselves navigating disputes about elections, ideology, identity, and public policy.
In such an environment, many leaders quietly ask a difficult question: How are we supposed to lead faithfully in a moment like this?
One helpful way to frame the challenge is with three simple observations about leadership in a polarized culture.
Christian leaders cannot stay ahead of it.
They will struggle to stay abreast of it.
But they must remain above it.
Understanding these distinctions can bring both realism and clarity to pastoral leadership today.
Why Leaders Cannot Stay Ahead
The first truth is simply a matter of humility. No leader today can stay ahead of cultural polarization.
The pace of social change is too rapid, the number of contested issues too large, and the cultural narratives too fragmented. Social media alone has reshaped the public square in ways that reward reaction and intensify conflict. Jonathan Haidt and other observers have noted how these digital environments amplify outrage, reinforce group identities, and make disagreement feel existential.[1]
For ministers and elders, this means the cultural terrain shifts faster than thoughtful leadership can map it. By the time one controversy fades, another emerges. New language appears. New ideological lines form. New anxieties surface within congregations.
Leaders who feel pressure to anticipate every cultural development or craft immediate responses to every public controversy will quickly find themselves overwhelmed.
The church does not need leaders who can predict every cultural turn. What it needs are leaders who can remain grounded in deeper truths.
Why Leaders Struggle to Stay Abreast
Even staying abreast of cultural polarization is difficult.
Healthy leadership requires some level of awareness. Pastors and elders cannot ignore the forces shaping the lives of their people. Congregations carry the emotional weight of the wider culture into church life — fear, anger, confusion, and loyalty to competing narratives.
But awareness does not require constant immersion.
In fact, many leaders are discovering that excessive exposure to cultural conflict can undermine their ability to shepherd well. When leaders become consumed by the same outrage cycles that dominate public discourse, their leadership begins to mirror the culture’s anxiety rather than offer an alternative to it.
Remaining thoughtfully aware, while refusing to be emotionally captured by every controversy, is an important discipline of pastoral leadership today.
Yet even this balance can be difficult to maintain.
Which is why the most important leadership responsibility lies elsewhere.
The Call to Stay Above
If leaders cannot stay ahead of polarization and may struggle to stay abreast of it, they must ensure that they remain above it.
The church’s deepest allegiance is not to a party, a movement, or a cultural tribe. Its allegiance is to Christ and the kingdom of God.
This theological clarity has profound practical implications. As Tim Keller often noted, the gospel both affirms and challenges every culture. Because of this, the church cannot fully identify with any political ideology. Yet it also cannot retreat from loving its neighbors or seeking justice in the world.
For Christian leaders, this means helping congregations inhabit society in a different way.
Practicing Leadership Above Polarization
What does leadership above polarization actually look like in the life of a congregation?
Several commitments become essential.
- Model calm, principled presence.
Anxious environments pressure leaders to react emotionally. Faithful leadership instead demonstrates steadiness, patience, and thoughtful discernment.
- Guard the church’s identity.
Political identities are powerful forces in modern culture. Leaders must continually remind congregations that their primary identity is found in Christ, not in ideological alignment.
- Teach better habits of disagreement.
In polarized societies, disagreement often leads to suspicion and hostility. Christian communities can learn to listen carefully, speak truthfully, and honor one another even when convictions differ.
- Exercise discernment about cultural engagement.
Not every controversy requires a congregational response. Wisdom often involves choosing which issues genuinely require pastoral guidance and which ones do not.
Through practices like these, church leaders help their congregations resist the gravitational pull of polarization.
A Quiet but Powerful Witness
The church’s most compelling witness in polarized times may not come through public arguments but through the quality of its shared life.
When believers with differing perspectives continue to worship, pray, serve, and love one another, they demonstrate something increasingly rare in our culture: unity that does not depend on ideological agreement.
Such communities do not emerge automatically. They require patient leadership from pastors and elders who understand the pressures of the moment yet refuse to be defined by them.
Christian leaders cannot stay ahead of a polarized culture. They will often struggle to remain abreast of it.
But by God’s grace, they can remain above it.
And in doing so, they help the church bear witness to a kingdom that is not shaken by the conflicts of any age.
[1] Jonathan Haidt, “Why the Past 10 Years of American Life Have Been Uniquely Stupid,” The Atlantic, May 2022, https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/05/social-media-democracy-trust-babel/629369/
About the Author
Carlus grew up playing trombone, singing, and acting. This presumed call to entertainment arts was profoundly redirected by his conversion at age 17 and a small congregation that welcomed him as their teen preacher. This led to training at Lipscomb University (B.A.), Harding School of Theology (M.Div.), and Abilene Christian University (D.Min.).
Dr. Gupton’s first love is preaching and teaching the Word, which he has done for 50 years since he was 17 years old. He has served churches ranging in size from 15 – 800. In 2001, he expanded his ministry into teaching leadership, conflict, and spiritual formation. He taught at Johnson University (2001-2013) and the University of Tennessee School of Communication Studies (2001-2011). From 2014-2021, he was Professor of Ministry, Director of Field Education, and Co-Director of the Doctor of Ministry at Harding School of Theology. He is currently Director of the Doctor of Ministry and Professor of Ministry at Hazelip School of Theology, Lipscomb University.
Dr. Gupton has consulted with churches for 30 years. He has expertise in numerous forms of congregational development, is an ICF credentialed coach, and is certified in an extensive suite of psychometric instruments for leadership and team effectiveness. He published two websites, LifeandLeadership.com and DISCPersonalitySource.com.
Carlus and Ann have been married for 43 years and have two grown daughters, Erin and Katlyn (David) Nowers, and two grandsons. He reads voraciously, loves listening to music, enjoys TED Talks and Ken Burns documentaries, and runs slowly to the tunes of 70s classic rock.
Leave a Reply